Commercial insurance is at a pivotal crossroads. Traditional, incremental approaches can no longer keep pace with emerging risks—from pandemic aftereffects and geopolitical tensions to climate change and cyber threats. Today’s market demands proactive, data-driven innovation that goes beyond reactive and rigid product strategies.
Our study of 350 commercial insurance leaders across North America and Europe (including the UK) reveals a stark industry divide. Only 18% of carriers currently launch truly new products, though disruptive offerings are projected to rise to 31% within two years. Larger carriers lead this transformation: 87% prioritize new product development today—with expectations rising to 91%—compared to just 18% overall among smaller firms. Yet, only 21% of respondents are confident in their innovation efforts, and fewer than one-third are prepared to integrate real-time data. Notably, large insurers show a 72% readiness for real-time data compared to only 25% among smaller carriers.
Legacy constraints remain a significant barrier. More than 76% of carriers are not making meaningful structural changes, and 70% design products without anticipating risks five years ahead. With 83% of executives citing outdated systems as the primary obstacle, it is clear that many carriers are ill-equipped to meet the dynamic demands of tomorrow’s market.
Our clustering analysis further distinguishes market leaders, or Pioneers, from their more cautious Traditionalist peers. Pioneers invest heavily in flexible, cloud-based platforms (66%), form strategic technology partnerships (63%), and focus on data-driven underwriting (61%). They launch new products in an average of just 6.8 months, continuously adapting their offerings (84% vs. 20% for Traditionalists), and demonstrate a 79% higher readiness for real-time data integration.
These insights offer a clear blueprint for the future: To remain competitive, commercial insurers must transition from reactive policy providers to agile, proactive risk partners. Embracing digital distribution, leveraging smart data, and forging robust ecosystem partnerships are not optional—they are essential steps toward long-term growth and differentiation.
The message is unequivocal: The transformation of commercial insurance is already underway. Insurers that act decisively and innovate boldly will shape the future of risk management, while those clinging to outdated models risk being left behind. The time to act is now.
Evolving risk and market pressures
Crisis of confidence in innovation
Data integration and agility gaps
Legacy constraints and inflexible products
Transformation through agility
Digital distribution and ecosystem integration
Pioneers vs. Traditionalists
The road ahead
To read the complete report, click the download button below.
Register now for immediate access of HFS' research, data and forward looking trends.
Get StartedIf you don't have an account, Register here |
Register now for immediate access of HFS' research, data and forward looking trends.
Get Started