Retail and consumer goods enterprises are battling multiple fronts—margin pressure, shifting consumer preferences, operational complexity, and a relentless technology drumbeat. Yet, while the noise around generative AI, automation, and omnichannel disruption is deafening, executives are asking sharper questions: What investments actually matter? Where should we double down now—and what’s worth betting on for the future?
To move beyond tech hype cycles, we introduce a 2×2 investment matrix—as depicted in Exhibit 1—that categorizes major innovation themes by two axes: ROI maturity (proven vs. unproven) and impact horizon (near-term vs. long-term). The result is a pragmatic tool to help retail and CPG enterprises assess which initiatives to accelerate, which to build toward, which to experiment with, and which to approach cautiously.
This matrix was shaped by insights from more than 25 executive briefings across IT, BPO, and consulting providers active in retail and consumer goods. While many of these providers were analyzed as part of HFS’ formal Horizons vendor assessments, this report is a spin-off analysis for enterprise leaders—it does not position or rank vendors, rather, it highlights patterns in buyer behavior and strategic focus.
Source: HFS Research, HFS Horizons on exploring the future of intelligent retail and CPG ecosystems, 2025
Our matrix defines four investment categories:
This category captures investments that have clearly demonstrated business value and are ready to scale now. These are not pilots—they are operational imperatives.
Hyper-personalization, driven by AI recommendation engines and GenAI content creation, is delivering double-digit uplift in revenue per user. Retailers leveraging tools such as Salesforce Einstein or Adobe Target are achieving higher conversion and loyalty—especially in Asia-Pacific, where digital retail has leapfrogged into personalization-first paradigms.
Omni-fulfillment strategies—including buy online pickup in store (BOPIS), curbside pickup, and ship-from-store—are now foundational, supported by cloud-based inventory management and AI-driven demand forecasting. Enterprises mastering this coordination enjoy 30% higher customer lifetime value and more agile supply chains.
Micro-fulfillment centers are helping to meet the growing demand for same-day delivery in urban markets, while bonded warehouses are improving global cash flow and customs agility. Loyalty programs, often powered by cloud-native analytics and personalized engagement strategies, are regaining strategic relevance—especially when enhanced by GenAI-driven content and mobile app integration.
Finally, data-fueled product innovations—such as launching private-label SKUs based on trending ingredients or unmet category demands—is cutting time to market and increasing launch success rates. Retailers and CPG brands embracing this approach are using digital twins, consumer sentiment analysis, and predictive modeling to shape product roadmaps in near real time.
In short, these initiatives deliver tangible ROI, boost agility, and elevate customer experience. They should be scaled without delay.
Strategic plays are enterprise-wide transformations with a solid business case that takes time to deliver. They demand investment, integration, and change management.
End-to-end AI supply chain orchestration represents a strategic pivot toward intelligent autonomy. Retailers are building digital twins of their supply networks, integrating the Internet of Things (IoT), real-time data lakes, and AI agents that simulate scenarios and proactively reroute logistics in response to external shocks—be it weather events or supplier delays. These systems reduce stockouts, optimize inventory, and enhance customer service—but require multi-year transformation to achieve.
Robotic automation in warehousing has already been proven to be effective in flagship deployments. Autonomous mobile robots (AMRs), vision-based sorting arms, and robotic pick-pack systems show 2x to 3x productivity boosts. Yet, scaling across diverse facility formats and integrating into legacy operations takes time and cultural shifts.
Blockchain, once seen as mere hype, is emerging as a backbone for transparency and traceability—especially in food safety, ethical sourcing, and high-value goods. Platforms such as IBM Food Trust are helping large consumer packaged goods (CPG) companies and grocers reduce fraud, accelerate recalls, and meet rising compliance demands.
Data monetization, often through retail media networks (RMNs), is transforming data into a high-margin product. Retailers such as Walmart and Tesco are monetizing shopper behavior data through partner-facing dashboards and ad platforms. However, building secure data exchanges, clean rooms, and monetization governance takes time and talent.
Finally, autonomous factories and lights-out warehouses represent the far end of strategic automation. These use AI-controlled machines, edge computing, and real-time analytics to operate with minimal human intervention.
While still nascent, the early adopters are proving that fully digitized operations can outperform traditional setups in throughput and cost efficiency—though only in select categories today.
These plays are not optional. They define long-term competitiveness—but require cross-functional commitment and ecosystem integration.
In this quadrant, we find initiatives with promise but unproven or volatile ROI. Leaders here are testing, iterating, and preparing for what may scale.
Subscription commerce is one such play. While companies such as Nike or P&G are seeing gains from D2C subscription models, many others are learning that churn, acquisition costs, and delivery complexity can erode returns. Still, those who master personalization and delivery logistics stand to gain recurring revenue and deeper customer data.
Social commerce is another fast-moving frontier. Retailers are experimenting with livestream sales, influencer-led drops, and TikTok-native storefronts. ROI is clearer in China and Southeast Asia than in North America or Europe—but consumer trends suggest this may shift fast.
AR try-ons and pop-up experiences fall into this zone too. Virtual makeup mirrors and 3D furniture placement tools improve conversion and reduce returns—but require consumer behavior change and technical investment. Pop-up stores are creating marketing buzz and gathering experiential data, though ROI is often more qualitative than financial.
Other examples include digital shelf management, self-checkout technology, and mobile point-of-sale systems. Each offers operational upside but faces cost-benefit tradeoffs that need careful analysis.
Betting ground initiatives deserve investment but should be run through an agile, fail-fast, test-and-learn model.
These initiatives are driven by visionary ambition or long-term regulatory inevitability. While they may be critical in the future, their path to ROI today is murky.
Sustainability transformation is a clear example. Between ESG mandates in Europe and carbon taxes on the horizon, companies have no choice but to act. But most sustainability projects—be it switching to compostable packaging or electrifying fleets—have unclear short-term returns. Leaders must frame these efforts as risk mitigation and license-to-operate investments.
Drone delivery captures public imagination but remains far from mainstream due to regulatory complexity and infrastructure gaps. Although some rural pilots and medical use cases are proving viable, scalability is still years away.
Store modernization—from interactive mirrors and edge computing infrastructure to Just Walk Out experiences—promises to transform the in-store journey. But the investment requirements are high, and measurable business returns are still sparse. These remain largely flagship experiments.
Retail media networks also live partly in the uncharted zone. While Amazon and Walmart are printing ad dollars, many others are struggling to build compelling offerings or justify the returns to their brand partners. Execution—not concept—is the challenge here.
Uncharted initiatives must be pursued as strategic hedges: pilot discreetly, measure impact, and be ready to scale if and when they prove to be viable.
Retail and CPG leaders must:
Register now for immediate access of HFS' research, data and forward looking trends.
Get Started
If you don't have an account, Register here |
Register now for immediate access of HFS' research, data and forward looking trends.
Get Started
